Gummy Nightmares

🎮 Games like Gummy Nightmares

Enjoy the Mystery, First-Person, Indie, Single-Player gameplay in Gummy Nightmares? These 24 games are matched by gameplay features, genre, and developer, most similar first. Each one shows "what's similar".

1. 1

   Kiosk

   · 2024

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

   Kiosk is a horror cooking game where you prepare orders for late-night customers who visit…

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
2. 2

   Poppy Playtime: Chapter 5 - Broken Things

   · 2026

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

   Face off against the deadly puppetmaster behind the horrifying events of Playtime Co. In t…

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
3. 3

   Pathologic Classic HD

   · 2015

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

   In Pathologic players embark on a dark journey to explore a remote town built upon old tan…

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
4. 4

   Industria

   · 2021

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

   Industria is a first-person shooter that takes you from East Berlin into a parallel realit…

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
5. 5

   Ratshaker

   · 2024

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

   RATSHAKER is the fun and quirky solution to all your rat problems! Hold on to the RAT, sha…

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
6. 6

   Nosferatu: The Wrath of Malachi

   · 2003

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Single-Player

   It is a misty evening in the year of our lord 1912. The Pattersons, a poor but proud arist…

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
7. 7

   Despair

   · 2015

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

   The main character wakes up in a tunnel of the subway and tries to find out that happened …

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
8. 8

   Narcosis

   · 2017

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

   Narcosis is a this hauntingly immersive survival story set at the hostile depths of the Pa…

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
9. 9

   That Which Gave Chase

   · 2023

   ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

   A scientist, seeking to return to the expedition he had to abandon, hires a sled dog mushe…

   ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
10. 10

    Penko Park

    · 2020

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    Penko Park is a game about exploring an abandoned wildlife park. Meet its mysterious inhab…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
11. 11

    Roots of Insanity

    · 2017

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    Roots of Insanity is a fps/tps, survival/horror game designed and developed in Unreal Engi…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
12. 12

    The Occultist

    · 2026

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    The Occultist is a first-person narrative thriller. You play as Alan Rebels, a paranormal …

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
13. 13

    Stairs

    · 2015

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    STAIRS is a first-person atmospheric psychological horror game, inspired by real-life even…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
14. 14

    Creepy Shift: Roadside Diner

    · 2024

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    A broke young man takes on the night shift at a roadside diner. In the glow of the blood m…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
15. 15

    Dread Hunger

    · 2021

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    A game of horror, survival, and betrayal. Explorers path their ship through the unforgivin…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
16. 16

    Ontos

    · 2027

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    A sci-fi mystery set on the repurposed moon hotel Samsara. Uncover cryptic experiments, fa…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
17. 17

    There Are No Ghosts at the Grand

    · 2026

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    Inherit a crumbling English hotel and restore it by day—while battling ghosts by night. Wi…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
18. 18

    Betrayer

    · 2014

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    Betrayer is a first person action adventure game that takes you to the New World at the tu…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
19. 19

    Pathologic

    · 2005

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    Pathologic is a Russian survival-horror/RPG about a remote steppe town collapsing under a …

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
20. 20

    Pineview Drive

    · 2014

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    A one-of-a-kind horror shocker – a game aware of your fear! The game watches your every mo…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
21. 21

    Hollow

    · 2017

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    “I didn't care about this ship… facility… whatever… Had to… Something, deep in my brain, d…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
22. 22

    The Shattering

    · 2020

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    The Shattering is a first-person, story-driven, psychological thriller that takes place in…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
23. 23

    Those Who Remain

    · 2020

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Indie

    Those Who Remain is a psychological thriller that takes place in Dormont, a small town in …

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…
24. 24

    Hello Neighbor: Hide and Seek

    · 2018

    ✔ Also Mystery, First-Person, Single-Player

    Hello Neighbor: Hide & Seek follows the tragic story of the Neighbor’s family in this dram…

    ⚔️ Compare with Gummy Nightm…