American Arcadia

🎮 Games like American Arcadia

Enjoy the Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person, Comedy gameplay in American Arcadia? These 24 games are matched by gameplay features, genre, and developer, most similar first. Each one shows "what's similar".

1. 1

   Call of the Elder Gods

   · 2026

   ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person✔ Same developer (Out of the Blue Games)

   Journey to the far corners of the Earth and unearth ancient horrors in this Lovecraftian n…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
2. 2

   Jenny LeClue: Detectivu

   · 2019

   ✔ Also Mystery, Comedy, Puzzle Adventure

   Jenny LeClue is a story focused exploration adventure game with memorable characters, a un…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
3. 3

   Flipping Death

   · 2018

   ✔ Also Mystery, Comedy, Puzzle Adventure

   Possess the living, aid the dead and flip between the worlds of Flipping Death - a puzzlin…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
4. 4

   Q.U.B.E: Director's Cut

   · 2014

   ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

   Q.U.B.E: Director's Cut is the definitive version of the brain-twisting first-person puzzl…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
5. 5

   Q.U.B.E. 2

   · 2018

   ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

   Q.U.B.E. 2 is the sequel to the hit first-person puzzle game Q.U.B.E. You are Amelia Cross…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
6. 6

   Supraland: Six Inches Under

   · 2022

   ✔ Also Comedy, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

   Supraland Six Inches Under has exploration, puzzles, and combat! A first-person-metroidvan…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
7. 7

   Supraworld

   · 2025

   ✔ Also Comedy, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

   Supraworld is a first-person puzzle metroidvania. Be tiny in a handcrafted toy world. Expl…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
8. 8

   The Ball

   · 2010

   ✔ Also Comedy, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

   The Ball is a first person action-adventure game featuring a full single-player experience…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
9. 9

   Q.U.B.E. 10th Anniversary

   · 2022

   ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

   Entirely rebuilt from the ground up, Q.U.B.E. 10th Anniversary is the ultimate celebration…

   ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
10. 10

    Portal

    · 2007

    ✔ Also Comedy, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    Waking up in a seemingly empty laboratory, the player is made to complete various physics-…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
11. 11

    Hyperstacks

    · 2026

    ✔ Also Comedy, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    Hyperstacks is a VR world of combat, parkour, logic-driven puzzles, memorable characters, …

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
12. 12

    Fever Meme

    · 2025

    ✔ Also Comedy, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    Fever Meme is a comedy/parody game that pivots between multiple genres as it spits in the …

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
13. 13

    Minute of Islands

    · 2021

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, Indie

    Explore strange and wonderful islands and dark labyrinths below in this narrative puzzle p…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
14. 14

    Spirit of the North 2

    · 2025

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, Indie

    Unveil the mysteries of a beautiful ancient world in this breathtaking 3rd-Person Adventur…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
15. 15

    There Are No Ghosts at the Grand

    · 2026

    ✔ Also Mystery, Comedy, Puzzle Adventure

    Inherit a crumbling English hotel and restore it by day—while battling ghosts by night. Wi…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
16. 16

    Escape Room: The Sick Colleague

    · 2020

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    You only wanted to make a visit to your sick colleague, but what you encounter is beyond y…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
17. 17

    Poppy Playtime: Chapter 5 - Broken Things

    · 2026

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    Face off against the deadly puppetmaster behind the horrifying events of Playtime Co. In t…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
18. 18

    Agent A: A Puzzle In Disguise

    · 2015

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    A suave secret agent adventure game. Your mission (should you choose to accept) is to infi…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
19. 19

    Industria

    · 2021

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    Industria is a first-person shooter that takes you from East Berlin into a parallel realit…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
20. 20

    Runaway 2: The Dream of the Turtle

    · 2006

    ✔ Also Mystery, Comedy, Puzzle Adventure

    Runaway 2: The Dream of the Turtle is a point and click adventure game released by Péndulo…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
21. 21

    The Convenience Store

    · 2020

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    The Convenience Store is a J-horror game about a college girl on a night shift.

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
22. 22

    The Bookwalker: Thief of Tales

    · 2023

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    The Bookwalker is a narrative adventure where you play as Etienne Quist, a writer-turned-t…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
23. 23

    Despair

    · 2015

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    The main character wakes up in a tunnel of the subway and tries to find out that happened …

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…
24. 24

    Escape From Mystwood Mansion

    · 2023

    ✔ Also Mystery, Puzzle Adventure, First-Person

    In this first-person puzzle escape room game, you are trapped in the mysterious Mystwood m…

    ⚔️ Compare with American Arc…